This week I was interviewed on Diana Brewer’s podcast Jewish Grrrl Preacher Thing on Substack. I’m not sure when it will be released. The title topic was one of the questions she told me she would ask. I answered from next week’s and this week’s Torah readings. Sharing with you an approximation of what I said.
The cringeworthy passages are those which are violent, xenophobic and patriarchal. Next week’s reading, Vayishlach contains a passage that is all three of these
Our Patriarch Yaakov (Jacob) just returned from fleeing his father-in-law, has wrestled with angels and won. And the text Dina, the daughter of Leah and Yaakov goes out to visit the women of the town.
The prince, Shechem, son of Hamor takes her and forces her. Falls in love with her and seeks out Yaakov to marry her. Shimon and Levy, also children of Leah lie and trick their way to revenge.”You want our sister,” they say, “all the men in Shechem must be circumcised.” Three days later when recovering the brothers slaughter all the men in the town. The other brothers then come in and plunder the town. Jacob tells them they’ve done wrong, not for killing, mind you, but because they gave him a difficult reputation.
Sometimes in a case like this chasidic commentators will turn it to metaphor – saying it is an internal struggle In this case there are no higher level commentaries. Anita Diamant has written one in her book, The Red Tent, a modern midrash . Biblical text contains ancestral mythology- larger than life. This legend is almost absurdly mythical. That Shechem would be so besotted, so that 2 brothers could defeat an entire city.
When we discuss troubling test and wrestle with it it can help us to recognize abuse in our life and world, and perhaps to heal. I had this kind of healing experience studying lamentations with R Shulamit Sapir. We could edit all the troubling stuff out – Thomas Jefferson took the oath of office on such a Bible. But violence, and abuse are still very real, and wrestling with these texts, studying with a friend or teacher, can be a pathway to dealing and hopefully healing
And the text can turn around, and make my heart sing – Mah nora hamakom hazeh! And Jacob awoke from his dream, the one of the ladder that with its foot on the earth and its head in the sky. “Surely G8d is in the place and anochi lo yadati, I, I did not know!” & “How awesome is this place”. He has fled the only home he’s every known under threat of death by his own brother. He falls asleep with stones for a pillow and he dreams. Midrash says he hadn’t slept at night for the 14 prior years – he stayed up studying Torah. But its only when he surrenders to sleep that he can dream. He wakes to know that G8d us in THIS place, the diaspora. The place we are standing right now is awesome, and that G8d is with him. Every place where we allow ourselves to be open is awesome, every moment of our lives a blazing miracle and this spot of earth we stand on is holy ground if we awaken.
Leave a Reply